Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Martino's avatar

Cross-examination is one test no tool can take for the witness. A witness who memorized a prepared account often breaks on the second follow-up question. A student who memorized a prepared essay faces the same risk in a seminar discussion.

Adelina Raheel's avatar

I'm a student and a writer, and I use AI, so I read this half nodding and half defending myself. Where you're right, you're very right. The struggle is the learning. Nobody gets stronger watching someone else lift. The wedding speech question is the real cost to me, because that doubt is already leaking onto things people did write themselves. So maybe the answer isn't only keeping the tool out of the room. What if we graded the process again, the drafts and the crossings-out, and not just the finished page?

1 more comment...

Ready for more?