1 Comment

When I was in the appellate division of the USAO SDFL, back in the early 80s, we would get very long, elaborate statements of the case. Our answer brief typically said:

"Appellant Jon My was found guilty of conspiracy to bore everyone to death, in violation of 18 U.S.C. 1111 (DE 1291). He was sentenced to 120 years in prison, a fine of $2.65, and 5 years of supervised release (DE 1983). Notice of Appeal was timely filed (DE 2255).

If there was an important motion that was litigated in the district court and a subject of the appeal, we would include a short reference to it such as.

"Appellant filed a motion to dismiss on the grounds that agents of the Bureau of Land Management, conducted a warrantless search of Appellant's backyard and discovered a 900-page manuscript entitled "A Practitioners Guide to the Blue Book." (DE 1060). That motion was denied after a three-week hearing and the court's order is the subject of argument II on appeal (Initial Br. p. 260).

Nothing more was really needed, especially because we were the appellee.

Expand full comment